Research Article
From Curriculum Transition to Maturation:
A Mixed-Methods Evaluation of the Educational Environment in Outcome-Based Medical Education
Issue:
Volume 2, Issue 3, September 2026
Pages:
41-49
Received:
7 October 2026
Accepted:
16 October 2026
Published:
29 October 2026
Abstract: Background: As outcome-based medical education (OBME) becomes established, students’ experiences offer insight into strengths and unresolved implementation challenges. Earlier cohorts at the Defence Services Medical Academy (DSMA) reported broadly favourable educational environments alongside concerns about assessment, workload, faculty support and social life. Objective: To assess the educational environment of 26th Intake interns and examine experiences that contextualise their Dundee Ready Education Environment Measure (DREEM) scores. Methods: This explanatory sequential mixed-methods study surveyed 33 interns using the 50-item DREEM, followed by purposively sampled individual interviews with 10 students. Descriptive statistics summarised survey scores; interview transcripts were thematically analysed using MAXQDA. Findings were integrated through an explanatory joint display. Results: The mean overall DREEM score was 134.2/200. Domain means (mean ± standard deviation) were 32.4 ± 5.9 for Students’ Perceptions of Learning, 29.6 ± 5.2 for Students’ Perceptions of Teachers, 25.3 ± 4.4 for Students’ Academic Self-Perception, 28.2 ± 4.8 for Students’ Perceptions of Atmosphere and 18.7 ± 3.7 for Students’ Social Self-Perception. Interviews identified five themes: growing adjustment to student-directed learning; improved but inconsistent assessment clarity; the importance of accessible feedback; peer-based learning support; and tensions between academic workload and social wellbeing. Conclusion: Interns generally viewed their environment positively, but their narratives identify differences in assessment communication, access to faculty and opportunities for rest and social interaction. These descriptive, single-cohort findings can inform local quality improvement; they do not establish that curriculum maturation caused changes from prior cohorts.
Abstract: Background: As outcome-based medical education (OBME) becomes established, students’ experiences offer insight into strengths and unresolved implementation challenges. Earlier cohorts at the Defence Services Medical Academy (DSMA) reported broadly favourable educational environments alongside concerns about assessment, workload, faculty support and...
Show More
Review Article
Teaching Health Professions Students When Not to Trust Generative AI: A Theory-Informed Framework for Verification-Scaffolded Case-Based Learning
Issue:
Volume 2, Issue 3, September 2026
Pages:
50-60
Received:
3 August 2026
Accepted:
14 August 2026
Published:
9 November 2026
Abstract: Background: Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) can produce fluent, context-responsive explanations and clinical suggestions, but the same fluency can conceal factual, evidentiary, or reasoning errors. Health professions students therefore need more than access skills or generic warnings: they need repeated practice deciding when AI advice is warranted, when it requires verification, and when it should be rejected. Aim: To propose a theory-informed, operational framework for teaching appropriate reliance on GenAI through case-based learning. Approach: A focused critical synthesis integrated four bodies of scholarship: GenAI in health professions education, trust and automation bias in human-AI interaction, metacognition and self-regulated learning, and case-based learning. The purpose was conceptual integration rather than exhaustive evidence retrieval or estimation of intervention effects. Framework: Verification-Scaffolded Case-Based Learning (VS-CBL) is a six-phase cycle: Commit, Consult, Challenge, Corroborate, Calibrate, and Consolidate. Students first make and rate an unaided judgment, then consult a documented AI system. They actively test the response for omissions and counterevidence, verify pivotal claims against authoritative sources, decide whether to accept, modify, or reject the advice, and complete an accountable final response plus an unaided transfer task. Faculty prevalidate cases, vary AI accuracy and error subtlety, preserve patient privacy, and scale oversight to clinical risk. Implications: VS-CBL shifts the educational target from AI use or satisfaction to appropriate reliance. It supports measurement of overreliance, underreliance, verification quality, confidence-accuracy calibration, reasoning quality, and delayed independent transfer. The design is adaptable across medicine, nursing, pharmacy, dentistry, rehabilitation, public health, and allied health programmes, including settings with limited connectivity. Conclusion: The educational question is not whether students should trust GenAI in general, but whether trust is warranted for a particular claim, task, and level of risk. VS-CBL offers a testable curriculum architecture for making that judgment visible and teachable. Its effectiveness and implementation burden require prospective, multicentre evaluation.
Abstract: Background: Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) can produce fluent, context-responsive explanations and clinical suggestions, but the same fluency can conceal factual, evidentiary, or reasoning errors. Health professions students therefore need more than access skills or generic warnings: they need repeated practice deciding when AI advice i...
Show More